Note ·

Courage is the only virtue you cannot fake

EthicsEntrepreneurshipRisk

Chapter 13 of Nassim Nicholas Taleb’s Skin in the Game, “The Merchandising of Virtue”, contains the line I wish I had remembered from my first reading: “Courage is the only virtue you cannot fake.” Everything else can be performed. Generosity can be a press release, kindness can be a strategy, an opinion can be shared when it is safe to share. Courage costs something by definition, and the cost is what makes it real.

Taleb’s test for virtue follows from that. “Sticking up for truth when it is unpopular is far more of a virtue, because it costs you something,” he writes, and the price is usually your reputation. Joining a crowd that is already shaming someone is the opposite: safe, popular, and in his words “a mixture of bullying and cowardice.”

The part I keep coming back to is his advice to young people who come to him wanting to reduce poverty or save the world. He gives them three rules:

  1. “Never engage in virtue signaling”
  2. “Never engage in rent-seeking”
  3. “You must start a business. Put yourself on the line, start a business.”

Take bounded risks, he says, and if you get rich, which is optional, spend it generously on others. “Courage (risk taking) is the highest virtue. We need entrepreneurs.”

I agree with this more than with most advice on how to do good. It matches what I believe about who carries progress: not the people with the best intentions about the world in general, but the people who put themselves into one concrete thing and answer for it. It is also what I mean when I say “skin in the game” in everyday speech, as I wrote in my review of the book: ownership, daring, and enough of yourself in something that it can make the world a little better.

    Open the full search →